Walter Badge Methodology

How we measure newsletter performance. Every score is deterministic, auditable, and based on fixed assumptions.

Methodology Version 3.1.2 • Last updated February 2026

Measurement, Not Advice

We measure what newsletters recommend. We don't tell you what to do with that information. We are a ruler, not a coach.

Fixed Assumptions

All newsletters are evaluated under identical assumptions for entry, exit, position sizing, and fill prices. No special treatment.

Full Audit Trail

Every recommendation extraction, mapping decision, and outcome calculation can be traced and independently verified.

The Walter Score

Score = 0.35(Performance) + 0.35(Risk) + 0.15(Process) + 0.15(Consistency)

Performance

35%

Cumulative modeled return
Risk-adjusted return (Sharpe)
Win rate across closed positions
Average gain vs. average loss

Risk Management

35%

Maximum drawdown frequency
Stop-loss adherence rate
Position sizing discipline
Volatility-adjusted exposure

Process Quality

15%

Clarity of recommendations
Parsability of trade instructions
Consistent formatting over time
Completeness of entry/exit criteria

Consistency

15%

Rolling 3-month return stability
Grade variance over time
Publication frequency adherence
Signal-to-noise ratio

Grade Scale

AAA94–100

Exceptional. Top-tier performance with strong risk management and consistency.

AA88–93

Excellent. Consistently strong returns with disciplined process.

A82–87

Good. Solid performance with room for improvement in some areas.

BBB68–81

Average. Mixed results with notable strengths and weaknesses.

BB58–67

Below average. Underperformance in multiple scoring components.

B45–57

Weak. Significant concerns about risk management or consistency.

C–CCC0–44

Poor. Persistent underperformance or serious process issues.

NR—

Not Rated. Insufficient data to generate a reliable grade (< 90 days of signals).

Execution Assumptions

To ensure apples-to-apples comparisons, all modeled positions use the same execution assumptions regardless of the newsletter source.

Buy Orders

Filled at ASK price

If received after market close, filled at next open ASK.

Sell Orders

Filled at BID price

If received after market close, filled at next open BID.

Position Size

$1,000 per signal (default)

Equal-weighted. User can override in settings for personal tracking.

Slippage

0 basis points

We model zero slippage. Real-world results may vary.

Commissions

Not included

Modeled returns are gross of commissions and fees.

Crypto

24/7 market assumed

Crypto assets filled at time of extraction with 5-minute delay.

Important Disclaimer

Walter Grades is a measurement tool, not an investment advisor. All returns shown are hypothetical and modeled under fixed assumptions. Past modeled performance does not guarantee future results. Walter Grades does not recommend, endorse, or advise on any investment. The Walter Score is a standardized metric, not a buy/sell signal. Always do your own research and consult a licensed financial advisor.

View Grades Directory